We ordered a Tuxedo French Cream cake for Christmas Eve. The cake was ready for pickup at the scheduled time on Christmas Eve morning. The pickup process was very organized with no wait time. The cake looked beautiful with the red and green trim on top of the chocolate ganache. We had added raspberry jam filling to the traditional buttercream filling. The cake was delicious.

Outstanding coffee cake and donuts!! Will make it a regular stop to pick some up anytime I find myself in 'stallis...

Amazing cake-tasting arrangement, wonderful cakes, and service was fantastic!! We encourage all to patronize this gem!

Wish Aggie's was still in St. Francis. Love all their goodies and recommend them highly. I'm trying to remember the name of the pastry I used to get. It was folded pastry filled with fruit in the middle and frosting on top. I always got it with Door County Cherries. Might have to make a trip to West Allis!

Did a photo cake; it was astonishing! Beautifully crafted and absolutely delicious. Marble with raspberry filling. Highly recommended!

I was at a baby shower that ordered pies and they were amazing. My favorite was their cherry pie. Best I have ever had

Excellent choice of bakery. Great area to sit and snake and everything is FRESH!. The areas are clean and it smells like baking as you walk in. If you're on a diet this would not be the place for you as it's not average dried up stuff in a case. THIS is mouth watering and you will want to take some home for later.

I went to Aggie's for the fist time about 2 weeks ago and I am now a huge fan. I was with my vegan sister and inquired if any vegan options were available, and they did have a few vegan options. I purchased a cream filled coffee cake, it was loaded with cream, and a couple of chocolate torte squares. Both were absolutely delicious! (Especially the coffee cake). I totally recommend this bakery.

I was here last month and there are so many desserts to choose from. I highly recommend and it's not very pricey.

Billy welcomed us into this wonderful world of Aggie's beautiful desserts. He couldn't have been more pleasant and helpful to us. He's got a great sense of humor and really made our trip there enjoyable. He was extremely accommodating to answering my questions and giving us the best service he could offer. I highly recommend this place for the elephant ears that I was looking for. I'm from California and we don't have those back there and I was excited to see them. I was born and raised in Milwaukee so I know what their local favorites are, and that was one of them.